| Paakko | Paakkonen | Paananen | Paatolo | Paavola | Pachel | Packard | Packenham |
| Packer | Padden | Paddock | Page | Pagett | Paggen | Pahan | Pahngord |
| Paige | Paintner | Pajari | Paju | Pajukoski | Pajunpaa | Pajuoja | Pakish |
| Pakonen | Palan | Palashewski | Paler | Pallack | Palm | Palmer | Palmerton |
| Palmquist | Palo | Palomaki | Palovich | Palubicki | Palvick | Palzer | Pancratz |
| Pangborn | Paknow | Pannek | Pantsari | Papa | Papenfuss | Papke | Parages |
| Parcham | Parchem | Parduhn | Parfenow | Parish | Park | Parker | Parkhill |
| Parkin | Parkinen | Parkins | Parks | Parr | Parson | Parsons | Parta |
| Partain | Partanen | Partridge | Parviainen | Pary | Pascel | Paschke | Pasko |
| Passi | Passoja | Pastir | Patrick | Patron | Patscher | Patsie | Patten |
| Patterson | Pattison | Patton | Patzoldt | patzwald | Paul | Paulsen | Paulson |
| Paulsrud | Pauna | Paune | Paup | Paurus | Pausch | Pautto | Pavin |
| Pawelk | Pawlitschek | Pawlowski | Payk | Payne | Peabody | Peach | Peacock |
| Pearce | Pearson | Pease | Peaslee | Peasey | Pechnich | Peck | Peckrul |
| Pedersen | Pederson | Peeters | Peffer | Pegnovich | Pehrson | Peichel | Peipho |
| Peirson | Peisderski | Pekkala | Pekulick | Peldo | Pelerau | Peleske | Pelkey |
| Pellie | Pelphrey | Peltier | Pelto | Pelton | Peltoniemi | Pember | Pendergrast |
| Pendle | Pengra | Penick | Pennie | Penny | Penpease | Penrose | Penttilla |
| Penwarden | Peplenski | Pepper | Peppling | Pera | Perala | Perault | Perdue |
| Pergande | Perhaj | Perina | Peritz | Perius | Perkins | Perkinson | Perkkio |
| Perle | Perleberg | Perlinger | Permann | Perna | Pernage | Pernula | Pero |
| Perreault | Perreten | Perrson | Perry | Persey | Person | Personius | Persons |
| Perszyk | Perton | Perzik | Peschel | Pesola | Pester | Peter | Peterka |
| Peterman | Petermann | Peters | Petersen | Peterson | Petrick | Petrie | Petroff |
| Petronon | Petru | Petschl | Petterin | Petterson | Pettit | Pettitt | Petzold |
| Pexsa | Peyerl | Pfalzgraff | Pfannkuch | Pfeffer | Pfefferle | Pfeifer | Pfeiffer |
| Pfeifle | Pflugradt | Phelan | Pheliph | Phelps | Pherson | Phersson | Philipp |
| Phillifso | Phillips | Philo | Phingobe | Phinney | Piatt | Picard | Piccard |
| Picco | Pick | Pickard | Pickit | Picklesimer | Pickrain | Picotte | Piechouski |
| Piehl | Piekarski | Piekkola | Pieper | Piepgras | Piepgros | Piepho | Piepkorn |
| Pierce | Piersol | Pierson | Piesch | Pietsch | Pihlaja | Pihlajamaa | Piikka |
| Piilola | Piippo | Piirato | Pikal | Pikkaraine | Pikkarainen | Pikop | Piku |
| Pilger | Pilgrim | Pillsbury | Pils | Pine | Pingree | Pinkney | Pinkowski |
| Pippo | Pirkola | Pishney | Pitheon | Pitka | Pittit | Pitts | Pitzel |
| Pitzl | Pixley | Pladsen | Pladson | Plagens | Plagenz | Plante | Plantz |
| Platt | Platzer | Plessel | Pletan | Plough | Plowman | Ployhart | Plum |
| Plummer | Pnamesterg | Poach | Pochardt | Pocta | Podatski | Podcimik | Pogue |
| Pohjola | Pohl | Pohtilla | Poika | Point | Poirier | Pokenoga | Pokezwinski |
| Pokrzywinski | Polacki | Polacky | Polar | Polaschek | Polchow | Polipnick | Politeske |
| Politiski | Politiskie | Poll | Pollard | Pollom | Polman | Polo | Polson |
| Poltiske | Polum | Pomerenke | Pomercy | Pompi | Pontius | Ponto | Poole |
| Poore | Pope | Popejoy | Poplan | Poppanen | Poppen | Poppler | Porkka |
| Porkkonen | Porkkunen | Porter | Porth | Poser | Posey | Posl | Poss |
| Possehl | Post | Posti | Pote | Poti | Potom | Potratz | Potter |
| Pottila | Potts | Poulsen | Poulson | Pourrier | Powell | Powelson | Powers |
| Powis | Powslawsky | Poykko | Poynter | Poynton | Pozozo | Praestlien | Praidy |
| Prall | Pranke | Prasaug | Pratridgeii | Pratt | Pravitz | pream | Preble |
| Prechel | Preitauer | Premes | Prenevost | Prentice | Prentiss | Presler | Prestbo |
| Prestegaard | Preston | Pretts | Prettyman | Preuss | Preusse | Prevost | Pribbernow |
| Price | Priebnow | Priem | Priess | Priest | Prim | Primasing | Prischmann |
| Prkic | Proehl | Prostlien | Proffitt | Prohl | Protase | Proulx | Provost |
| Przybylski | Psenicka | Puchalla | Puckett | Pudas | Puel | Pufas | Pugh |
| Puhrman | Pulaka | Pulford | Pulkinen | Pullen | Pulver | Puphal | Puranen |
| Pushing | Puskanen | Putaas | Putikka | Putnam | Puttonen | Puupera | Pyhala |
| Pyle | Pyolm |
| Surnames Found in our Cemetery Records | |||||
| P | |||||